Company Snapshot: A Fixed & Indexed Specialist
EquiTrust Life Insurance Company is a mid-sized carrier that has built its business specifically around fixed and fixed indexed annuities, managing approximately $33.6 billion in assets. Unlike many carriers covered on this site, EquiTrust has not diversified into variable annuities or registered index-linked annuities — its entire annuity shelf is built on traditional insurance-basis products rather than securities.
Publicly available 2026 third-party sources cite a B++ (Good) rating from AM Best, alongside A- (Strong) ratings from both S&P and Fitch — two of the three major agencies. EquiTrust’s NAIC complaint index for individual annuities is reported at approximately 0.21, well below the 1.00 national average, meaning the company generates roughly one-fifth the complaint volume expected for a carrier of its size; the Better Business Bureau assigns EquiTrust an A+ grade. Current ratings and figures should be verified directly with each agency and with EquiTrust before this page is published, since ratings and outlooks can change.
Notable Ownership: Magic Johnson Enterprises
A detail worth stating plainly, since it is a genuine point of interest for consumers researching this carrier, is that EquiTrust is controlled by an entity affiliated with Magic Johnson Enterprises, the business and investment organization founded by NBA Hall of Famer Earvin “Magic” Johnson. This is an unusual ownership structure in the annuity industry, where most carriers are owned by mutual policyholder structures, publicly traded insurance holding companies, or institutional asset managers rather than a founder-led business enterprise. This ownership detail does not by itself change how EquiTrust’s guarantees work, but it is a distinctive fact worth including for visitors curious about who stands behind the carrier.
A Fixed and Indexed-Only Lineup — No Securities Products
Every product EquiTrust sells is a fixed-insurance-basis contract: multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs), traditional fixed annuities, and fixed indexed annuities. EquiTrust does not manufacture variable annuities or registered index-linked annuities (RILAs), so no product on this page — or anywhere in EquiTrust’s current lineup — requires a securities license to sell or a prospectus for the consumer to review. This is worth stating as a genuine characteristic of the carrier: a buyer working with EquiTrust is, by definition, choosing from products with a guaranteed floor against index-linked losses rather than any product carrying direct market risk to principal.
Reading Past a Single Rating: A Split Financial Strength Picture
| Measure | Result | Context |
|---|---|---|
| AM Best rating | B++ (Good) | One tier below the A- to A++ range where most other carriers on this site fall. |
| S&P rating | A- (Strong) | In line with several other carriers on this site. |
| Fitch rating | A- (Strong) | In line with several other carriers on this site. |
| NAIC complaint index (individual annuities) | Approximately 0.21 | Well below the 1.00 national average — roughly one-fifth the expected complaint volume for a carrier of its size. |
| BBB grade | A+ (not accredited) | Reflects strong customer-service marks independent of financial strength ratings. |
The EquiTrust Product Family
| Product | Product Type | Key Structure | What It’s Designed For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Certainty Select Series | Multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) | Guaranteed fixed rates locked in from day one for a selected term, with a free withdrawal provision for penalty-free access to a portion of contract value each year. | Conservative savers who want pure accumulation with no market exposure and no indexed complexity. |
| ChoiceFour | Traditional fixed annuity | A single premium deferred annuity featuring a one-year annual reset interest rate, with additional premiums allowed in the first year only. | Savers who want a simple, renewable fixed-rate structure rather than a locked multi-year term. |
| MarketFive / MarketSeven | Fixed indexed annuity (accumulation-focused) | Medium-length surrender periods (commonly around 5 to 7 years) with index-linked growth potential and a zero-loss floor against index declines. | Accumulation-focused buyers who want a moderate surrender commitment without a large upfront bonus. |
| MarketMax | Fixed indexed annuity (growth-focused) | Positioned for buyers who prioritize maximum indexed upside participation over other features such as a bonus or income rider. | Consumers who want to maximize index-linked growth potential within a principal-protected structure. |
| MarketValue | Fixed indexed annuity (income-focused) | Built around a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB) rider for consumers whose primary objective is guaranteed lifetime income. | Retirees who want a fixed indexed annuity with income planning as the central feature rather than an add-on. |
| Bonus FIA series (MarketForce Bonus, MarketPower Bonus, MarketTen Bonus, MarketEdge Bonus) | Fixed indexed annuity (bonus-focused) | A range of premium bonus structures — from a roughly 6% bonus on premiums paid in the first five years up to a 20%+ bonus spread over the first three years on the most aggressive product — paired with surrender periods commonly ranging from 10 to 14 years depending on the specific product and bonus level. | Buyers who want an upfront bonus and are certain they will not need the money for the full surrender period, since larger bonuses generally come with longer surrender schedules. |
Which Product Fits Your Goal?
| If the Goal Is… | Consider Comparing… | Because |
|---|---|---|
| Simple guaranteed-rate accumulation, no indexed complexity | Certainty Select Series (MYGA) | Guaranteed fixed rates from day one with a free withdrawal provision, comparable to a CD. |
| A renewable fixed rate rather than a locked multi-year term | ChoiceFour | One-year annual reset structure with first-year additional premium flexibility. |
| Moderate-commitment indexed growth, no large bonus | MarketFive or MarketSeven | Medium surrender periods with index-linked growth and a zero-loss floor, without a bonus trade-off. |
| Maximizing indexed upside participation | MarketMax | Positioned specifically for buyers who prioritize index-linked growth potential above other features. |
| Guaranteed lifetime income as the primary goal | MarketValue | Built around a GLWB income rider rather than treating income as an optional add-on. |
| An upfront bonus, with a long time horizon | The Bonus FIA series (MarketForce, MarketPower, MarketTen, MarketEdge Bonus) | Offers a range of bonus percentages and surrender periods to match different bonus-vs-commitment preferences. |
Benefits to Consider
- One of the broadest bonus FIA menus of any carrier covered on this site, giving buyers more granular choice between bonus size and surrender-period length.
- A zero-loss floor on all fixed indexed products, meaning index-linked strategies do not reduce principal due to index declines.
- A notably low NAIC complaint index (approximately 0.21 versus a 1.00 national average) and an A+ BBB grade, both suggesting a strong customer-service track record.
- A death benefit included on all products, paying contract value to beneficiaries.
- Available exclusively through independent agents, allowing straightforward side-by-side comparison with other carriers rather than a captive-only distribution model.
- A fixed-and-indexed-only product philosophy, meaning every product is a straightforward insurance contract rather than a security requiring a prospectus.
As with any carrier, a feature is only a benefit if it matches the consumer’s actual goal. The largest bonus percentages in EquiTrust’s lineup come paired with the longest surrender periods (up to 14 years on some products), so a large bonus is only a genuine benefit for someone certain they won’t need that money for the full term.
Risks and Limitations
- EquiTrust’s B++ (Good) AM Best rating sits a full tier below most A-rated competitors covered on this site, which matters most for very large or very long-duration contract placements.
- Premium bonus products often offset their upfront enhancement through lower cap rates or participation rates over the life of the contract compared with non-bonus alternatives.
- The most aggressive bonus products carry surrender periods as long as 14 years — a meaningful commitment that should be weighed carefully against the bonus received.
- Volatility-controlled or proprietary index strategies can advertise higher participation rates that are not directly comparable to simpler S&P 500 cap-rate structures, since the underlying index engineering reduces both potential upside and downside.
- EquiTrust’s annuity-only, non-securities product philosophy means consumers specifically wanting a RILA or variable annuity will need to compare a different carrier on this site.
- Annuity guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of EquiTrust Life Insurance Company, not by FDIC insurance.
Consumers should request a current product brochure or illustration and state-specific disclosure directly tied to the exact product being considered, since terms vary by state and change over time.
Who Might Consider This Carrier?
An EquiTrust annuity may be worth reviewing for retirees and pre-retirees who want a deep menu of fixed indexed annuity bonus structures to choose from: bonus-focused buyers comparing the MarketForce, MarketPower, MarketTen, and MarketEdge Bonus products against each other, accumulation-focused savers comparing MarketFive, MarketSeven, or MarketMax, and income-focused buyers interested in MarketValue’s GLWB structure.
Who May Not Be a Fit
This carrier’s products may not be a fit for consumers who weight the AM Best rating most heavily among agencies and want to stay in the A- to A++ range across all three major agencies, buyers uncomfortable committing to a 10-to-14-year surrender period for a larger bonus, or those specifically shopping for a RILA or variable annuity, which EquiTrust does not offer.
FAQs: Your Questions Answered
Annuity contracts are generally governed by the state where the contract was issued, but the availability of specific products and bonus structures can vary by state. Consumers who relocate should review their contract with an advisor.
EquiTrust products are available through independent agents, allowing you to compare them side by side with other carriers. An independent comparison can help you evaluate EquiTrust’s MYGA and bonus FIA products against other carriers before you decide.
Review surrender charge schedules (especially for bonus products with longer terms), any income rider fees (such as those on MarketValue), and the specific cap or participation-rate trade-offs tied to any bonus feature.
Larger premium bonuses on products like MarketPower Bonus or MarketEdge Bonus generally come with longer surrender periods—up to 14 years on the most aggressive products—and can be paired with lower cap or participation rates than non-bonus alternatives.
Yes. MarketValue is built around a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB) rider as its central feature, and optional income riders are available on several of EquiTrust’s other fixed indexed products.
No. EquiTrust specializes exclusively in fixed and fixed-indexed annuities. It does not offer variable annuities or registered index-linked annuities, so no EquiTrust product requires a securities license to sell or a prospectus for buyers to review.
Money in an EquiTrust fixed indexed annuity is not directly invested in the market and is protected by a zero-loss floor against index declines. Withdrawals beyond the allowed free-withdrawal amount during the surrender period may still reduce value through a surrender charge.
Fixed and fixed indexed annuity guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of EquiTrust Life Insurance Company and are not the same as FDIC insurance. EquiTrust does not offer variable annuities or RILAs, so none of its products carry direct market risk to principal.
EquiTrust’s B++ (Good) AM Best rating sits one tier below the A- to A++ range where most competing carriers fall, even though its S&P and Fitch ratings are both A- (Strong). Review the specific factors behind AM Best’s assessment in AM Best’s published rating rationale.
EquiTrust carries a B++ (Good) rating from AM Best, a tier below most competitors on this site, but holds A- ratings from both S&P and Fitch and a notably low NAIC complaint index. Whether a specific EquiTrust product is a good fit depends on the product type, your comfort with its rating profile, and your retirement goals — not any single rating figure alone.
EquiTrust Life Insurance Company is controlled by an entity affiliated with Magic Johnson Enterprises, the business and investment organization founded by NBA Hall of Famer Earvin “Magic” Johnson — an unusual ownership structure compared with most annuity carriers, which are typically owned by mutual policyholder structures, public holding companies, or institutional asset managers.


