Company Snapshot: Privately Held, Employee-Owned Since 1886
North American Company for Life and Health Insurance was founded in 1886 and is headquartered in West Des Moines, Iowa. It was acquired by Sammons Financial Group in 1996 and has remained privately held and employee-owned ever since — meaning it is not publicly traded and, according to the company, is not subject to the short-term earnings pressure that public shareholders can create for competing carriers.
Publicly available 2026 third-party sources cite an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best, with S&P and Fitch ratings affirmed in 2025. North American is described as a consistent top-10 seller of both MYGAs and fixed index annuities, distributed exclusively through independent insurance agents in all 50 states — the company does not sell directly to consumers.
One Parent, Two Carriers: North American and Midland National
A structural detail worth making explicit — since it is easy for a consumer or even an agent to overlook — is that North American and Midland National are sister companies, both owned by Sammons Financial Group. “Sammons Financial” is the marketing name for the parent, but consumers do not buy a policy directly from Sammons; they buy from one of its two primary annuity-issuing subsidiaries:
- North American Company for Life and Health Insurance is generally described as Sammons’ MYGA and fixed annuity workhorse, known for the Guarantee Choice MYGA series and a broad fixed indexed annuity lineup.
- Midland National Life Insurance Company is the larger of the two subsidiaries by total assets and is generally positioned as Sammons’ primary fixed indexed annuity and life insurance carrier, with its own separate product lineup.
Both companies carry their own separate ratings and product catalogs, and a quote from one is not automatically comparable to a quote from the other — but both ultimately answer to the same parent, Sammons Financial Group. Consumers comparing “North American vs. Midland National” are really comparing two siblings under one privately held parent, not two fully unrelated competitors.
The North American Product Family
| Product | Product Type | Key Structure | What It’s Designed For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guarantee Choice | Multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) | Available in 2, 3, 5, 7, and 10-year terms; 10% annual free withdrawal; no annual fees; $10,000 minimum premium; consistently competitive rates across most terms. | Rate-focused buyers who want top-of-market MYGA returns from an A+ carrier. |
| Builder Plus | Fixed indexed annuity (accumulation/income) | Multiple index crediting options including the S&P 500 and Goldman Sachs Momentum Builder; optional income rider; 10-year surrender period. | Long-horizon accumulation buyers who also want future guaranteed income planning flexibility. |
| Rapid Builder | Fixed indexed annuity (accumulation-focused) | 7-year surrender variant of Builder Plus with slightly lower caps in exchange for a shorter commitment period. | FIA-curious buyers who want index-linked growth without a full 10-year lockup. |
| NAC Guaranteed Allocation | Fixed indexed annuity (accumulation-focused) | 5-, 7-, and 10-year surrender options; all fixed and indexed rates guaranteed for the full surrender charge period; four preset Model Blend allocation options with automatic annual rebalancing. | Consumers who want turnkey, diversified index allocation without building a custom strategy themselves. |
| VersaChoice | Fixed indexed annuity (liquidity-focused) | Features an Enhanced Liquidity rider allowing penalty-free withdrawals of up to 20% of account value annually — double the industry-standard 10% — for an additional cost. | Consumers who want meaningfully more penalty-free access to funds than a typical FIA offers. |
| Income Pay Pro 10 | Fixed indexed annuity (income-focused) | Pairs index crediting with a guaranteed compound roll-up (commonly cited around 8%) applied to the income value for up to 10 years, in exchange for an annual rider charge (commonly cited around 1.15%). | Retirees planning a long deferral period who want the income base to grow substantially before activating lifetime income |
| Income (SPIA) | Single premium immediate annuity | Converts a lump sum into income payments with flexible payout structures, including period certain, life only, installment refund, and cash refund options. | Retirees who want guaranteed income starting now, with payout-structure flexibility. |
A Standout Feature: VersaChoice’s Enhanced Liquidity
VersaChoice’s Enhanced Liquidity rider is worth explaining on its own because it addresses one of the most common objections to fixed indexed annuities: limited access to funds during the surrender period. Where most FIAs cap penalty-free withdrawals at 10% of account value per year, VersaChoice’s optional rider raises that ceiling to 20% annually, for an additional cost. This does not eliminate surrender charges on withdrawals beyond that amount, but it meaningfully increases how much a contract owner can access without penalty in a given year compared with a standard FIA structure.
Which Product Fits Your Goal?
| If the Goal Is … | Consider Comparing … | Because |
|---|---|---|
| A competitive simple guaranteed rate | Guarantee Choice (MYGA)Guarantee Choice (MYGA) | Consistently competitive rates across 2- to 10-year terms with a relatively low $10,000 minimum. |
| Long-horizon growth with future income flexibility | Builder Plus | Multiple index strategies over a 10-year surrender period with an optional income rider. |
| FIA growth without a full 10-year commitment | Rapid Builder | 7-year surrender period, trading slightly lower caps for a shorter lockup. |
| Turnkey diversified index allocation | NAC Guaranteed Allocation | Preset Model Blend options with automatic annual rebalancing simplify strategy selection. |
| More penalty-free access than a typical FIA | VersaChoice | The Enhanced Liquidity rider allows up to 20% annual penalty-free withdrawals, double the industry standard. |
| Maximizing future guaranteed income over a long deferral | Income Pay Pro 10 | Guaranteed compound roll-up on the income value for up to 10 years before income begins. |
| Guaranteed income starting now | Income (SPIA) | Converts a lump sum into income payments with flexible payout structure options. |
Benefits to Consider
- Privately held, employee-owned structure, which North American frames as freedom from short-term shareholder pressure and a focus on long-term commitments to policyholders.
- Consistent top-10 positioning among both MYGA and fixed index annuity sellers, with Guarantee Choice regularly appearing in top-rate comparisons.
- VersaChoice’s Enhanced Liquidity rider, offering meaningfully more penalty-free access than most competing FIAs.
- NAC Guaranteed Allocation’s preset Model Blend options, which simplify diversification for consumers who don’t want to build a custom index allocation.
- Income Pay Pro 10’s guaranteed compound roll-up, useful for long-deferral income planning.
- A long operating history dating to 1886, including having weathered both World Wars and the Great Depression.
As with any carrier, a feature is only a benefit if it matches the consumer’s actual goal. VersaChoice’s higher liquidity ceiling comes at an additional rider cost, so it is most valuable to someone who genuinely expects to need more than the standard 10% annual access — not a default upgrade for every buyer.
Risks and Limitations
- North American does not sell directly to consumers; all products are distributed through independent insurance agents, so a purchase requires working with a licensed professional.
- Income Pay Pro 10’s guaranteed roll-up applies to the income value used to calculate future lifetime withdrawals, not to the account’s lump-sum cash value, and carries an ongoing rider charge.
- VersaChoice’s Enhanced Liquidity rider carries an additional cost and, like all FIA riders, deductions for strategy charges or optional benefits could exceed interest credited in some periods.
- Surrender periods on FIA products commonly run 7 to 10 years, with withdrawals beyond the free allowance subject to a surrender charge.
- North American does not appear in some recent J.D. Power customer satisfaction studies, meaning it was not included in the study rather than having scored poorly — but this also means less independent satisfaction data is available compared with carriers that do participate.
- Annuity guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of North American Company for Life and Health Insurance, not by FDIC insurance.
Consumers should request a current product brochure, illustration, and state-specific disclosure directly tied to the exact product being considered, since terms vary by state and change over time.
Who Might Consider This Carrier?
A North American annuity may be worth reviewing for retirees and pre-retirees who want a privately held, employee-owned carrier with competitive MYGA and FIA rates: rate-sensitive savers comparing Guarantee Choice against other MYGAs, accumulation-focused buyers comparing Builder Plus, Rapid Builder, or NAC Guaranteed Allocation, consumers who specifically want more penalty-free liquidity through VersaChoice, and income-focused buyers comparing Income Pay Pro 10’s roll-up structure.
Who May Not Be a Fit
This carrier’s products may not be a fit for consumers who want a direct-to-consumer purchase path, buyers seeking variable or registered index-linked annuity options (which North American does not offer, unlike some carriers on this site), or those who want extensive third-party customer satisfaction data to inform their decision.
FAQs: Your Questions Answered
Annuity contracts are generally governed by the state where the contract was issued, but the availability of new products and riders can vary by state. Consumers who relocate should review their contract with an advisor.
Independent agencies such as AM Best, S&P, Moody’s, and Fitch assign financial strength ratings based on an insurer’s ability to meet its claims obligations. Check these ratings directly with the rating agency for the most current information.
An independent comparison can help you evaluate North American’s MYGA and FIA products against other carriers — including sibling company Midland National — rather than focusing on a single illustration or headline rate.
Review surrender charges, strategy charges on enhanced crediting methods, and optional rider fees such as the Enhanced Liquidity rider on VersaChoice or the income rider charge on Income Pay Pro 10.
No. North American annuities are sold exclusively through independent insurance agents in all 50 states; the company does not sell directly to consumers.
Money in a fixed indexed annuity such as Builder Plus or NAC Guaranteed Allocation is not directly invested in the market and is not reduced by index declines. In some periods, deductions for strategy or rider charges could exceed credited interest, reducing overall value.
Safety depends on the product type. Fixed and indexed annuity guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of North American Company for Life and Health Insurance and are not the same as FDIC insurance.
VersaChoice is a fixed indexed annuity known for its optional Enhanced Liquidity rider, which allows penalty-free withdrawals of up to 20% of account value annually — double the standard 10% offered on most competing FIAs — for an additional cost.
North American carries an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best and is a consistent top-10 seller of both MYGAs and fixed index annuities. Whether a specific North American product is a good fit depends on the product type, current rates, and your retirement goals — not the carrier name alone.
No, but they are sister companies. Sammons Financial Group owns both North American and Midland National, which is the marketing name for the parent company’s member companies. They carry separate ratings and product lineups, so a quote from one does not represent the other, but both ultimately answer to the same privately held parent.


